Job Opportunity: Underwriting Supervisor

About the Role

Germania is seeking an experienced and motivated Underwriting Supervisor to lead and inspire our underwriting team. This is an excellent opportunity for a seasoned insurance professional ready to take the next step in their career. You will oversee complex underwriting decisions, mentor team members, and drive continuous improvement in underwriting practices.

As a key member of our leadership team, you will ensure compliance with company and regulatory standards while contributing to the overall success of our underwriting operations.

Key Responsibilities

• Lead, coach, and support a team of underwriters, providing regular performance feedback and development opportunities.

• Review and approve complex underwriting cases, including excess liability and high-value property risks.

• Foster strong broker relationships through clear communication, timely service, and consistent follow-through.

• Ensure adherence to underwriting guidelines and regulatory requirements.

• Identify and implement opportunities to improve underwriting processes and operational efficiency.

• Contribute to initiatives that enhance workflow, accuracy, and service delivery.

Qualifications

• Post-secondary education or equivalent business experience.

• Completion or active pursuit of the CIP designation.

• Minimum of five years of experience as a multi-line insurance professional.

• Demonstrated leadership and mentoring experience.

• Strong analytical, communication, and decision-making skills.

• Experience with Guidewire and knowledge of the Mutual insurance industry are considered assets.

Key Skills & Attributes

• Proven ability to lead and support a team in a collaborative environment.

• Expertise in managing complex policies with minimal oversight.

• In-depth understanding of underwriting principles, internal processes, and regulatory standards.

• High attention to detail and strong problem-solving capabilities.

• Proactive mindset with a focus on continuous improvement and team development.

Why Join Germania?

Founded in 1878, Germania Mutual continues to be a leader in the insurance industry, known for our progressive approach and innovative work environment. We are committed to maintaining the integrity and stability that have defined our organization for over a century.
At Germania, we value integrity, collaboration, and innovation. We believe in rewarding hard work and supporting our employees' growth and well-being. Here's what we offer:

• Competitive salary

• Comprehensive benefits package

• Pension plan Flexible hybrid work model

Ready to Apply?

If this sounds like the right fit for you, we’d love to hear from you! As much as we would like to reach out to all applicants, only those selected for an interview will be contacted.
Germania Mutual is an equal opportunity employer.
Please respond by July 31, 2025, to:

Sarah Holliday

Underwriting Manager
Germania Mutual Insurance
PO Box 30, 403 Mary St.
Ayton, ON N0G 1C0