Claims Counsel, Specialty Insurance

Toronto, ON
Hybrid
Posted Oct 14, 2026
1 position

$120,000–$150,000 / year

Opens an external site

Employment type: Full-time
Experience level: Mid-level · 2+ years
Minimum education: Professional degree
Posting language: English
Working hours: 40 hours per week

Job summary

The Claims Counsel is responsible for managing a portfolio of specialty insurance claims from initial notice through resolution, including coverage analysis and litigation management. They will also collaborate with internal stakeholders and provide professional, empathetic service to insureds and brokers.

Job details

At Trisura, we expect more because we believe it can be done better. We are a young, growth oriented team with a commitment to exceptional talent and have been named one of Canada’s Top Small and Medium Employers since 2017. Our growth and our entrepreneurial style, niche market position and development opportunities ensure that our people see the results of their commitment reflected in the company’s success. We are currently seeking a qualified individual for the following opportunity in our Toronto office: CLAIMS COUNSEL / CLAIMS EXAMINER, SPECIALTY INSURANCE TORONTO, ONTARIO The Claims Counsel / Claims Examiner, reporting directly to the Vice President, Specialty Insurance Claims, will be responsible for the investigation, evaluation, negotiation and resolution of specialty insurance claims. This is a growth position as the Specialty Insurance claims team is expanding. Responsibilities include: Managing a portfolio of specialty insurance claims from first notice of loss through resolution. Conducting coverage analysis and determining policy response. Drafting coverage correspondence, reservation of rights letters, and denial letters as required. Communicating with insureds, counsel, brokers, third party adjusters, vendors and claimants. Establishing and maintaining accurate reserves throughout the life of the claim. Managing litigation and negotiating settlements within authority level. Authorizing payments in accordance with company guidelines and authority levels. Maintaining complete and accurate claim documentation. Collaborating with underwriting, risk management, and other internal stakeholders. Providing exceptional customer service while managing claims in a professional and empathetic manner. Acting as a resource for various business units. As an integral member of the team, you will bring: Ability to thrive in a challenging, fast-paced environment. Excellent written and verbal communication skills. Strong critical thinking and analytical capabilities. Forward thinking and collaborative approach to problem solving. High level of accuracy, organization, and attention to detail. Proven ability to manage multiple priorities in a fast-paced environment. Self-directed work style with the ability to operate in a nimble entrepreneurial environment. Ability to learn quickly. A passionate, participative, service-oriented attitude Qualifications LL.B. or J.D. from a recognized university or CIP designation completed or in process (preferred but not required). Membership in good standing with the LSO, if applicable. A minimum of 2 to 5 years of specialty insurance claims handling experience or experience in private practice specializing in insurance law; Excellent analytical, negotiation, and decision-making skills. Proficiency with Microsoft Office applications and claims management systems. Location: Downtown Toronto – Hybrid Salary: The expected salary in this position is within the range of $120,000 - $150,000 This salary range reflects the expected base compensation for the role across Canada. Actual compensation will be determined based on factors such as experience, qualifications, and scope of responsibilities. Trisura provides this range in good faith in accordance with applicable legislation. This posting does not correspond to an existing vacancy but is part of our proactive recruitment efforts. #LI-Hybrid If you are looking for a career in an exciting and rewarding company, are driven to excel, thrive in a team environment and want to contribute to the success of an organization that values your contribution, we would like to hear from you! We are committed to an inclusive and barrier-free workplace that reflects the diversity in each of our offices across Canada. Accommodations will be provided on request for candidates taking part in all aspects of our recruitment and selection process. We thank all candidates for their interest however only those selected for an interview will be contacted. Trisura, headquartered in the heart of Canada’s financial district, is a specialty lines insurer with a focus on Surety, Specialty Insurance, Property & Casualty, and Warranty products. Trisura brings innovative solutions and expertise through a select network of both national and regional brokerage firms. The company, founded in 2006, and operating across North America with offices in Toronto, Ottawa, Halifax, Montréal, Calgary, Vancouver, Stamford. Denver, Chicago, Philadelphia and Oklahoma City, is uniquely positioned to satisfy all varieties of risk in Contract, Commercial and Developer Surety, Directors' and Officers' Liability, Fidelity, and Professional Liability including Media Liability, as well as Warranty products. trisura.com/careers

What you’ll do

Requirements

Candidates must have 2 to 5 years of specialty insurance claims or insurance law experience and possess strong analytical and negotiation skills. An LL.B., J.D., or CIP designation is preferred, along with membership in good standing with the LSO.